The aftermath
Update 10th Feb: The Darker Projects team have produced a rather excellent audio drama version of Silver Spiral that you can download here.
Well. What a strange week. I am honestly stunned by the reaction to the Doctor Who story, it's amazing how many people have read, commented on and linked to it. It's turned up in some odd places too - I find it quite astounding that the original Skymania article about the story was posted on the Scientific American website! It's been linked to by Gallifrey Base (currently it's the only post that shows up under their "science" tag), io9, Kasterborous, it was picked as an Editor's Selection by Dr SkySkull on Research Blogging, someone made an entry for it in the Doctor Who wiki (although I doubt it will stay there), and it even turned up in the Big Finish forum. Wow. Even the audio version seemed to go down well, although I'm very much looking forward hearing to the Darker Projects version of it with David Ault as the Doctor (the next best thing to having David Tennant and Freema Agyeman read it!).
Not all the feedback was positive, but it was at least mostly constructive. One comment was that the formatting made it hard to read, so apologies for that. Several people also pointed out that there had been sharks in the oceans for a while by 35 million years BC (what's a decimal point between friends?). Ooops, entirely my fault. I could say that I'm an astronomer, not a palaeontologist, but that's a cop out as I was trying to be at least slightly educational. There's no excuse. Sorry.
Several people objected to the lack of knowledge and the incredulous tone that I gave Martha. She sounds that way because I needed her to! It's intended as an early Martha story, before she's got used to the whole idea of being able to go any place and any time, so I think the tone is justified. As for her lack of physics knowledge, well, her character is clever (I'm not disputing that), but she's a medic not a physicist. I knew quite a few medics at uni, and a generally bright bunch they were, but they couldn't tell you the first thing about how the Sun worked. I couldn't name the bones of the hand without looking them up - I may be a Dr, but I'm not that sort of doctor.
But, most of the comments were very positive, and a very big thank you to everyone who gave me feedback (good or bad). I wrote it for a bit of fun, with the hope that it might be slightly educational, and it seems to have done what I hoped it would and reached a far larger audience than I ever expected. I'd really love to see a bit more actual science in Doctor Who since, as has also been noted by several of those who commented, the original concept for the show was to have an educational aspect to it. I doubt anyone from the Beeb will ever read this but, just in case: come on guys, it's not hard! That child-like excitement you see in the character when there's something new or unusual: that's exactly what it feels like to be a scientist!
It's years since I wrote anything fictional, but I think I will try doing it more often after the reaction this one had. There's plenty more science to go at, and there will be a more substantial story behind it next time...
Posted by Megan on Thursday 04th Feb 2010 (05:39 UTC) | 8 Comments | Permalink
Comments: The aftermath
I think the original creators of Doctor Who would be proud of you.
This is exactly the sort of thing Doctor Who was created for, "To enrich people's lives with programes that inform, educate and entertain."
Science and imagination have always gone hand in hand, as you have ably proven. Bravo!
Posted by betawho on Saturday 06th Feb 2010 (06:04 UTC)
Thanks betawho :-)
Posted by Megan on Saturday 13th Feb 2010 (06:43 UTC)
Parall¡§¡§lement ¡§€ la m¡§ºme lign¡§¦e, il ya ceux qui choisissent d'obtenir des r¡§¦pliques de replique montre en raison de qu'ils sont g¡§¦n¡§¦ralement beaucoup plus abordable. Si vous n'avez pas besoin d'argent ¡§€ gaspiller sur des objets somptueux comme les montres de cr¡§¦ateurs, et vous avez encore vous trouvez dans voulons d'une replique montre luxe, vos plus beaux devinez peut-¡§ºtre d'aller pour la r¡§¦plique de montre.Puis il ya ces r¡§¦pliques de montres qui peut ¡§ºtre con?u et int¡§¦gr¡§¦ une telle approche que vous venez va vraiment avoir beaucoup de services ¡§€ partir. Ce qui signifie qu'ils sont robustes et de meilleure qualit¡§¦. En fait, ils sont tr¡§¡§s chers que la montre rolex standard de faux. N¡§¦anmoins, vous aurez le service d'une rolex submariner originale et sa semble ¡§ºtre comme ¡§€ un moindre co?t. ¡§€ long terme, ce sont presque comme les montre burberry haut de gamme seulement ils ont ¡§¦t¡§¦ fabriqu¡§¦s par des personnes diff¡§¦rentes. Ils seront toujours bien vous servir.Vous devez ¡§¦galement se rappeler que la montre cartier bon march¡§¦ est aussi bon que tout regarder. Il peut vous offrir un service identique que l'original. La distinction majeure est une qu'il n'est pas concepteur-il a juste le regard identiques parce que le replique montres.Pour venir ¡§€ une conclusion appropri¡§¦e, inutile de dire qu'il ya de tr¡§¡§s nombreuses raisons pourquoi les gens vont pour les fausses montres. Certains sont attir¡§¦s par leur ressemblance aux Rolex deepsea originales. Puis il ya ces parmi nous qui ne peuvent s'offrir une montre d'autres si ce n'est pas une r¡§¦plique. Cependant, il ya ces personnes rares parmi nous qui iront ¡§€ une plus grande r¡§¦pliques de montres ¡§€ prix en raison de leur proximit¡§¦ que montres design que tout montre peut obtenir.
Posted by adasdad on Wednesday 07th Sep 2011 (15:01 UTC)
May be interested in pack for "sexual assault" to step down awkward mess behind Kahn, IMF (International Monetary Fund) ushered in the first Nvzhang Lagarde.replica hermes bags And the French "won" means that the olive branch as a totem of eastern and western hemispheres and the mysterious organization, has never slipped out of the traditional "European mask."
Fortunately, in the eyes of many international scholars, Laggard¡¯s election will make her attitude toward China's goodwill to be released. Have a high profile in public suggests, but also the current IMF Managing Director Zhu Min, the Special Adviser to the station "plays a key role in a very appropriate" prominently.
Yesterday, the central bank spokesman said he hoped to continue advancing Lagarde IMF reform, increase in emerging market and developing countries in the IMF governance structure representation.
Financial Chanel
Almost every photo on a spread in the world, are unable to find traces of Lagarde knitted brows furrowed. White short hair, always polished able hair,hermes replica handbags classical elegant smile, close set and leave the body Chanel Hermes bag ... if I do not know the identity of the seriousness of the former French finance minister, may be mistaken for a fashion guru.
Interestingly, the British "Daily Telegraph" website recently published an article to "the financial world or to save Chanel Coco ? Nicolas Sarkozy" in the title of the article, the 55-year-old has the capability of women in politics who gave away the unique dual endowment.
The discerning fashion talent in the Lagarde's early childhood may be planted on the gene. 1956, Lagarde was born in Paris in nine districts of the north bank of the Seine. And who gave birth to the modern, Dadaism and other pioneers of the left bank of ideas "cradle" than the right bank is the luxurious, practical, commercial hub.
University English professor father's identity, so Lagarde enough to live comfortably middle-class childhood to live life. 15-year-old expansion of the French swimming championships bronze of the vigorous figure into the bag,birkin replica the more she shine in the political arena after the foundation of a beautiful body. After his father's death, the publisher of the independent spirit of the standard mother Bing Lagarde also determines the fate of 17 years of age.
Posted by hermes on Thursday 08th Sep 2011 (05:31 UTC)
This [url=http://www.orderchanelonline.com]chanel handbags[/url] the Xuanduan, a dark robe [url=http://www.orderchanelonline.com]chanel purse[/url] to the western black tie and a priest's full ceremonial dress called a Fusha. A lanshan was worn as an official or academical dress. A business needs to be profitable i.
Posted by jkgyjh on Thursday 15th Sep 2011 (03:28 UTC)
The traditional cotton yukata or the summer Kimono, the woven cotton haori or the short silk jacket and dyed ikat kimono would be chanel handbags informal clothing. These informal Japanese chanel purse would customarily only be worn as daily wear, to a bathhouse or for informal friend and family visits. Formal Japanese clothing is rather contrasting, either very elaborate or a simple elegant design is considered formal.
Posted by hjfgjy on Thursday 15th Sep 2011 (03:29 UTC)
Hello, everybody, the good shopping place laptop battery.Welcome to buy cheap and high quality ac adapter and power adapter, laptop batteries, laptop charger, cheap laptop batteries, laptop battery, replacement battery for your notebook computer.a32-f3, a32-f3 battery, eee pc 1000 battery, a32-f5, asus a32-f3 battery, a32-f5 battery, asus a32-f5 battery, asus n61 battery, asus eee pc 1005 battery, asus eee pc 1000 battery, asus m50 battery, a32-f82, a32-m50, asus g73 battery, asus n53 battery, asus eee pc 1000h battery, asus a3 battery, asus eee pc 1005ha battery, asus k52 battery, asus a6 battery, a32-f82 battery
Posted by Bill Kuehn on Friday 16th Sep 2011 (08:18 UTC)
The prizes of life are at the end of each discount ugg boots journey, not near the beginning; discount uggs boots and it is not given to me to know how many steps are necessary in order discount ugg to reach my goal. Failure I may still encounter at the thousandth step, yet success hides behind the next bend in the road. ugg boots discount Never will I know how close it lies discount uggs boots unless I turn the corner.
Posted by discount ugg boots on Tuesday 20th Sep 2011 (07:36 UTC)